• Editorial Policy
  • Privacy Policy
  • Who Are We
  • About
Monday, July 14, 2025
  • Login
The Pearl Times
  • Home
  • News
    • National
    • Business
    • Sports
    • World
  • 2026 Elections
  • People
  • Featured
  • Viewsroom
  • PROSE & POETRY
  • Archives
No Result
View All Result
  • Home
  • News
    • National
    • Business
    • Sports
    • World
  • 2026 Elections
  • People
  • Featured
  • Viewsroom
  • PROSE & POETRY
  • Archives
No Result
View All Result
The Pearl Times
No Result
View All Result
Home Featured

Andrew Mwenda: Magufuli was like Idi Amin & a disastrous imitation of Kagame

Andrew Mwenda, Idi Amin Dada and John Pombe Magufuli. Magufuli's equal was Idi Amin who would make decisions based on his dreams, the caresses of his mistresses and the jests of buffoons (as Akena Adoko put it).

Andrew Mwenda, Idi Amin Dada and John Pombe Magufuli. Courtesy Photos

Magufuli’s misguided African choir | Andrew M. Mwenda

Since his death, former Tanzanian president, John Pombe Magufuli, has been an object of much praise from many commentators, including a large number Tanzanians.

He has been lionized among others for his fight against corruption, public sector incompetence and profligate government spending.

He did this through highly publicized stunts – firing public officials at a whim and on the spot, yelling at foreign investors and contractors in public and arbitrarily cancelling public contracts he did not like.

While one could admire his motivations and intentions, I could not agree with Magufuli’s approach to reform.

I was repulsed by the emotionally charged, personalized and arbitrary way in which he conducted public affairs.

I am always puzzled by a large section of African elites. In one second they argue that power should be institutionalized and not personalized.

In another, when a leader does what is emotionally satisfying to them but in a personalized fashion running roughshod over institutions, they cheer him along.

They claim to oppose dictatorship and insist that power must be checked and balanced. Yet when a leader emerges who does what they demand but does it using arbitrary power, they support him.

That was the love affair between Magufuli and this section of African elites.

Magulufi’s presidency was the ultimate manifestation of both the crisis and the contradictions of our elites. Upon coming to power, he exercised a degree of arbitrariness only reminiscent of Idi Amin.

He would enter a government facility, be it hospital or school, and seeing wrong things, he would fire the entire management on impulse and on the stop without first establishing the circumstances under which such failures arose.

This arbitrary use of power does excite the hoards but should never be a basis for public sector management especially in 21st Century Tanzania.

But first a clarification: I am not against the use of a strong authoritarian hand to correct distortions created over decades of incompetence, inertia and corruption.

I believe that reforming a deeply entrenched system requires a leader to exercise power without being hamstrung by unnecessary checks and balances.

Attempts to uphold the highest standards of due process are more likely to abort reform.

This is because entrenched interests can use the procedures of government, which they are adept at, to block reform. So, forceful action by a determined leader is often a necessary precondition for effective and successful reform.

However, there is a difference between forcefulness and arbitrariness, between institutionalized power and personalized highhandedness and between being authoritarian and being a village tyrant.

Magufuli represented arbitrariness, personalized highhandedness and acted as a village tyrant. His were not reforms but emotionally charged and erratic personal interventions.

All too often, he destroyed whatever was there without replacing it. He achieved more public acclaim than actual improvements.

Reform cannot be based on emotions. It must be based on thoroughly considered facts. This requires the reformer to act systematically using some minimum institutionalized processes.

It cannot be personalized to one’s feelings, acting in the heat of the moment. Even in medieval times, people did not govern without any recourse to established norms or procedures.

It is possible that in his many reckless decisions, Magufuli may have corrected some mistakes. But even then, his emotionally charged and highly personalized arbitrariness cannot be justified by such accidental success.

I have seen reform elsewhere which has worked. One example is post 1986 Uganda; the other, post 1994 Rwanda. In 1990s, President Yoweri Museveni carried out far-reaching reforms.

He knew what he wanted.

But he used institutions such as the Army Council, the Army High Command, the National Resistance Council and cabinet to make critical decisions such as the return of Asian properties, return of ebyaffe, privatization, civil service retrenchment, etc.

His reforms were successful and have been sustainable because doing them through institutions gave them a collective mandate and therefore a good degree of legitimacy.

Another example is President Paul Kagame of Rwanda.

In the early to mid 2000s, he carried out comprehensive reforms of the public sector that (I suspect) Magufuli sought to imitate.

These reforms included reducing the number of districts, the size of cabinet and parliament, removing luxury official cars from government officials, cutting down on necessary international travels etc.

All of these decisions were first taken to the Political Parties Forum, then to cabinet and finally to parliament and adopted.

They did not emerge from below but from Kagame personally and he used all these institutions to ensure buy-in i.e. to build a broad national consensus in favor of a lean and efficient government.

Even in his fight against corruption, where he can be accused of being highhanded, Kagame has always acted not on impulse but on facts based on investigations.

Once he has done the investigations and established culpability, he moves quickly and decisively to arrest and prosecute the culprits. In most cases the state in Rwanda has lost corruption cases against the accused public officials.

This only shows that corruption is hard to prove but also that the president could have acted on either false or incomplete information. The bottom-line here is that he acted on the basis of an investigation (institutions), not on his personal whims.

Magufuli was a disastrous imitation of Kagame. He lacked the subtlety of a reformer and the ideological grounding of a revolutionary.

He was a boxer who tied a cloth on his face and went boxing everything in the ring – the referee, the attendants on both sides, the poles and the ropes. He only boxed his opponent by accident or luck.

His equal was Idi Amin who would make decisions based on his dreams, the caresses of his mistresses and the jests of buffoons (as Akena Adoko put it).

His decision to chase away Ugandans of Asian descent was, apparently, based on a dream.

His decision to allow Palestinian high jackers use Entebbe was spontaneous based on an interview with a French film producer.

Magufuli was lionized by a section of African elites because of their deep sense of psychological insecurity.

Growing up in poor countries dominated by images of the affluence of rich nations, African elites want to leapfrog to modernity overnight. But it is impossible to cheat social evolution, and transformative change takes generations.

If some nations in East Asia transformed rapidly, it is because they had a long history of statehood, a shared national consciousness, accumulated social and human capital and norms and values that lent themselves easily to capitalist transformation.

African elites, in their impatient desire to see their nations transformed in an instant to look like Europe or South Korea, have been clutching from one straw to another.

In one second they want democracy and its accompanying checks and balances while in another they want one man or woman, the magical leader, to perform a miracle.

Magufuli tapped into this.

He was a populist and a demagogue who abused power but attracted the adulation of the hoards. Many of his ill-informed decisions wrecked untold havoc on Tanzania and history will not absolve him of his impunity.

https://www.pearltimes.co.ugmemorable-quotes-here-are-magufulis-most-unforgettable-statements/

Andrew Mwenda is a Ugandan journalist, and owner of The Independent.

Disclaimer: The views expressed in articles published in the Viewsroom Section of The Pearl Times are those of individual writers and do not represent the official view of The Pearl Times, its directors, management and staff on the issue(s) addressed.

Opinion writers are individually responsible and liable for the omissions and misrepresentations in the work published by this medium of communication.

Editor’s Note: To be published in The Viewsroom, email your opinion, preferably less than 600 words, and photo to pearltimesug@gmail.com

Share this:

  • Click to share on Facebook (Opens in new window) Facebook
  • Click to share on X (Opens in new window) X

Related

Previous Post

Kadaga: Why I can’t leave speaker job for a man

Next Post

Miria Matembe: Kadaga has overstayed as speaker; she has failed to groom successor

Pearl Times Reporter

Pearl Times Reporter

Latest Uganda news, politics, business, health and entertainment coverage.

Related Posts

LIST: See Names of Teachers, Non-Teaching Staff Who Have Landed Government Payroll Jobs for Elgon Seed Schools (Bugisu and Sebei) LIST: Names of Teachers, Non-Teaching Staff Shortlisted for Oral Interviews (Tooro Seed Schools) LIST: Over 3800 Teachers, Nurses, Other Teaching Staff Shortlisted for Tooro, Bunyoro Seed Schools’ Payroll Jobs. Aptitude Tests Next Week LIST: See Names of 4200 Teachers (Graduates) Shortlisted for Aptitude Tests for Government Payroll Jobs (Teso, Elgon, Karamoja, Bukedi Seed Schools)
Employment

LIST: See Names of Teachers, Non-Teaching Staff Who Have Landed Government Payroll Jobs for Elgon Seed Schools (Bugisu and Sebei)

Prima Kadarshi Confesses: Yes, I Cheated on 'Broke' Mr Henrie With 'Rich' Medi Moore on Dubai Trip
Pearl Love

Prima Kadarshi Confesses: Yes, I Cheated on ‘Broke’ Mr Henrie With ‘Rich’ Medi Moore on Dubai Trip

R.I.P! Prof George W Kanyeihamba Dead
Featured

R.I.P! Prof George W Kanyeihamba Dead

Zambaali Bulasio Mukasa Opens Up on His Rumored Love Relationship with Isabella Tugume
Media Buzz

Zambaali Bulasio Mukasa Opens Up on His Rumored Love Relationship with Isabella Tugume

Former Nigerian President Muhammadu Buhari Dead
Africa

Former Nigerian President Muhammadu Buhari Dead

How to Handle Uganda's Ticking Bomb of Youth Unemployment -- Proposals by Museveni Challenger Who Once Hawked Bathing Sponges
Viewsroom

Unemployment Fueling Mental Health Crisis among ‘Working Age’ Ugandans

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Ad

Stay Connected

  • Trending
  • Comments
  • Latest
Archbishop Cyprian Lwanga accuses lawyers Ebert Byenkya, Julius Galisonga and Bainomugisha of pressurizing him over compensation money for church land in Entebbe and Nsambya.

Archbishop Lwanga Reports Top City Lawyers to Museveni Over Church Money

Minister claims mafia after her life over minerals row

Why Museveni is keenly Watching Companies Donating to Covid19 Fund

More Ugandan Covid patients recover but doctors’ allowances delay

Museveni, sacked EC secretary Sam Rwakoojo and NUP leader Bobi Wine

Were Top EC bosses fired over Bobi Wine NUP Party or Ballot Paper Printing scandal?

Watchman Ministries Pastor and Prophet Elvis Mbonye's anointed Joseph Kabuleta has announced his 2021 presidential bid.

Prophet Mbonye’s ‘Anointed’ Kabuleta declares 2021 presidential bid

Former Kampala deputy lord mayor Sarah Kanyike is one of the six dropped ministers appointed senior presidential advisors.

NEW CABINET: Museveni consoles Six DROPPED Ministers with Presidential advisor positions

PAYMENT ALERTS: Allowances for Gulu Sitting Deposited on MPs’ Bank Accounts. See How Much

PAYMENT ALERTS: Allowances for Gulu Sitting Deposited on MPs’ Bank Accounts. See How Much

LIST: See Names of Teachers, Non-Teaching Staff Who Have Landed Government Payroll Jobs for Elgon Seed Schools (Bugisu and Sebei) LIST: Names of Teachers, Non-Teaching Staff Shortlisted for Oral Interviews (Tooro Seed Schools) LIST: Over 3800 Teachers, Nurses, Other Teaching Staff Shortlisted for Tooro, Bunyoro Seed Schools’ Payroll Jobs. Aptitude Tests Next Week LIST: See Names of 4200 Teachers (Graduates) Shortlisted for Aptitude Tests for Government Payroll Jobs (Teso, Elgon, Karamoja, Bukedi Seed Schools)

LIST: See Names of Teachers, Non-Teaching Staff Who Have Landed Government Payroll Jobs for Elgon Seed Schools (Bugisu and Sebei)

Prima Kadarshi Confesses: Yes, I Cheated on 'Broke' Mr Henrie With 'Rich' Medi Moore on Dubai Trip

Prima Kadarshi Confesses: Yes, I Cheated on ‘Broke’ Mr Henrie With ‘Rich’ Medi Moore on Dubai Trip

R.I.P! Prof George W Kanyeihamba Dead

R.I.P! Prof George W Kanyeihamba Dead

Zambaali Bulasio Mukasa Opens Up on His Rumored Love Relationship with Isabella Tugume

Zambaali Bulasio Mukasa Opens Up on His Rumored Love Relationship with Isabella Tugume

Recent News

LIST: See Names of Teachers, Non-Teaching Staff Who Have Landed Government Payroll Jobs for Elgon Seed Schools (Bugisu and Sebei) LIST: Names of Teachers, Non-Teaching Staff Shortlisted for Oral Interviews (Tooro Seed Schools) LIST: Over 3800 Teachers, Nurses, Other Teaching Staff Shortlisted for Tooro, Bunyoro Seed Schools’ Payroll Jobs. Aptitude Tests Next Week LIST: See Names of 4200 Teachers (Graduates) Shortlisted for Aptitude Tests for Government Payroll Jobs (Teso, Elgon, Karamoja, Bukedi Seed Schools)

LIST: See Names of Teachers, Non-Teaching Staff Who Have Landed Government Payroll Jobs for Elgon Seed Schools (Bugisu and Sebei)

Prima Kadarshi Confesses: Yes, I Cheated on 'Broke' Mr Henrie With 'Rich' Medi Moore on Dubai Trip

Prima Kadarshi Confesses: Yes, I Cheated on ‘Broke’ Mr Henrie With ‘Rich’ Medi Moore on Dubai Trip

R.I.P! Prof George W Kanyeihamba Dead

R.I.P! Prof George W Kanyeihamba Dead

Zambaali Bulasio Mukasa Opens Up on His Rumored Love Relationship with Isabella Tugume

Zambaali Bulasio Mukasa Opens Up on His Rumored Love Relationship with Isabella Tugume

ADVERTISEMENT

Ad

The Pearl Times

The Pearl Times Is an online media publication for news and analysis from Uganda, the Greatest lakes Region and the world. The Pearl Times is your trusted source of news and analysis from Uganda and the rest of the world in the beats of politics, business, entertainment, technology, education and health.

Follow Us

Popular Posts

  • From Solomon Sserwanja's 'Audio' to Kakwanzi 'Leaked Video,' Here's How to Verify Fake or AI Generated Videos, Audios Elizabeth Kakwanzi Katanywa: So-Called Leaked Video & Dirty Politics of Western Youth MP Elections?

    Elizabeth Kakwanzi Katanywa: So-Called Leaked Video & Dirty Politics of Western Youth MP Elections?

    0 shares
    Share 0 Tweet 0
  • ‘Leaked Video’ Aside, Who are Elizabeth Kakwanzi Katanywa’s Opponents in Western Youth MP Election?

    0 shares
    Share 0 Tweet 0
  • Elizabeth Kakwanzi Katanywa Doesn’t Need to Campaign. ‘Leaked Video’ is Enough – Says Doreen Kabareebe

    0 shares
    Share 0 Tweet 0

Recent News

LIST: See Names of Teachers, Non-Teaching Staff Who Have Landed Government Payroll Jobs for Elgon Seed Schools (Bugisu and Sebei) LIST: Names of Teachers, Non-Teaching Staff Shortlisted for Oral Interviews (Tooro Seed Schools) LIST: Over 3800 Teachers, Nurses, Other Teaching Staff Shortlisted for Tooro, Bunyoro Seed Schools’ Payroll Jobs. Aptitude Tests Next Week LIST: See Names of 4200 Teachers (Graduates) Shortlisted for Aptitude Tests for Government Payroll Jobs (Teso, Elgon, Karamoja, Bukedi Seed Schools)

LIST: See Names of Teachers, Non-Teaching Staff Who Have Landed Government Payroll Jobs for Elgon Seed Schools (Bugisu and Sebei)

Prima Kadarshi Confesses: Yes, I Cheated on 'Broke' Mr Henrie With 'Rich' Medi Moore on Dubai Trip

Prima Kadarshi Confesses: Yes, I Cheated on ‘Broke’ Mr Henrie With ‘Rich’ Medi Moore on Dubai Trip

  • About
  • Advertise
  • Privacy & Policy
  • Contact

© 2024 - The Pearl Times by The Pearl Times.

Welcome Back!

Login to your account below

Forgotten Password?

Retrieve your password

Please enter your username or email address to reset your password.

Log In
error: Content is protected !!
No Result
View All Result
  • Home
  • News
    • National
    • Business
    • Sports
    • World
  • 2026 Elections
  • People
  • Featured
  • Viewsroom
  • PROSE & POETRY
  • Archives

© 2024 - The Pearl Times by The Pearl Times.

This website uses cookies. By continuing to use this website you are giving consent to cookies being used. Visit our Privacy and Cookie Policy.